Air Command Integrated Review Refresh 2023

For everything else UK defence-related that doesn't fit into any of the sections above.
Post Reply

With a £800m shortfall which of these do you think are unaffordable?

200 Aster 30 Block 1NT
0
No votes
8 Sea Protector UCAV
2
22%
2 E-7 Wedgetail AEW1
0
No votes
upgrade of tranche 2 and 3 Typhoons
0
No votes
6 A400M Atlas
7
78%
 
Total votes: 9

User avatar
AndyC
Member
Posts: 169
Joined: 11 Dec 2015, 10:37
United Kingdom

Air Command Integrated Review Refresh 2023

Post by AndyC »

Moving Beyond Austerity, 2015-23

The top priority for the MoD must be to provide sufficient forces to defend the UK’s airspace, territorial waters and ocean floor communication cables. That means maintaining a credible minimum nuclear deterrent and keeping hostile aircraft, ships and submarines out of range of being able to launch stand-off weapons at the UK or threatening vital shipping, air transport routes and electronic communications.

The RAF was the clear winner in SDSR15 with the standing up of two additional Typhoon Squadrons and orders for sixteen long-range Protector UCAV, nine Boeing P-8 Poseidon maritime patrol aircraft and two Shadow R2 aircraft, plus the retention of a Hercules C4 Squadron.

Between 2015 and the Integrated Review of 2021 (IR21), Air Command went further by ordering five Boeing E-7 Wedgetail AEW1 and committing to the development and retrofitting of tranche 3 Typhoons with the world leading European Common Radar System Mark 2 (ECRS2) multi-function array radar.

Unfortunately, IR21 failed to build on these commitments, but instead saw a reversal of policy and a return to cutbacks. The Sentinel R2, Hawk T1 (except those in the Red Arrows) and Hercules C4 were all retired in the summer of 2023. The thirty remaining tranche 1 Typhoons are being retired between 2025-27 and the barely adequate order for five Boeing E-7 Wedgetail AEW1 was cut to just three aircraft.

The Integrated Review Refresh 2023 (IRR23) exercise has provided a much needed opportunity to reassess the UK’s defence priorities within a realistic budget set to grow to 2.25% of GDP by 2025, including the replacement of weapons given to Ukraine and further growth in the budget for the nuclear deterrent.


Ballistic Missile Defence
Aster 30 Block 1NT.jpg
A major priority missing from IR21 was any commitment towards Ballistic Missile Defence (BMD). Nevertheless, in May 2022, this oversight was partially corrected when the UK joined the French-Italian BMD programme. This committed the UK to upgrade its existing 400 Aster 30 and Aster 15 missiles to Aster 30 Block 1B maritime standard. These improved missiles are capable of intercepting short/medium-range ballistic missiles and aircraft up to a range of 1,500 kilometres/900 miles. A further step forward was achieved in 2022 with an order for one very long-range ground based BMD Radar to replace RAF Fylingdales.

The standing up of a Squadron of twelve launch vehicles, each with eight ready-to-fire Aster 30 Block 1NT (New Technology) missiles, could provide an essential BMD for the UK mainland. These vehicles could be divided between three Flights with each assigned to a Sky Sabre Battery providing short-range air defence. An order for 200 new Aster 30 Block 1NT missiles should be placed this year with an objective of full deployment by 2026. In addition, development needs to continue of the Aster 30 Block 2BMD with a range of up to 3,000 kilometres/1,800 miles.


Frontline Squadrons

In peacetime, two frontline Squadrons based at RAF Lossiemouth share the role of northern Quick Reaction Alert (QRA), while two at RAF Coningsby share southern QRA. In addition a Flight based at RAF Mount Pleasant undertakes this role for the Falkland Islands. Four frontline Squadrons and a Flight is the minimum necessary requirement to provide continuous peacetime QRA coverage.

In periods of increased military tension Air Command’s principal role is to provide long-range air defence (up to 1,500 kilometres/900 miles) of the UK. This would be based on an effective BMD, advanced air superiority fighters, up to date AEW, modernised ground radar and aerial tankers. One BMD Squadron, four frontline air defence Squadrons plus one Squadron of AEW aircraft and one Squadron of A330 Voyager aerial tankers should be able to fulfil this role against likely credible threats.

With Russia’s increased aggression destabilising Eastern Europe, and continuing instability in the Middle East, the RAF has regularly deployed up to three Flights. They have been used to support NATO’s Baltic Air Policing, provide rotational deterrence for Romania as well as on-going operations based at RAF Akrotiri. Air Command requires three frontline multi-role Squadrons to maintain the minimum necessary support for the UK’s commitments to NATO and multi-national operations.

The maintenance of a continuous carrier strike capability has considerable implications for the deployment of combat aircraft. In peacetime, however, only one frontline Squadron needs to be at sea at any particular time. This role could be rotated between three Squadrons altogether, with one at sea and two based at RAF Marham. In a period of rising tension all three could be deployed to a Queen Elizabeth class aircraft carrier. Three frontline fleet air defence Squadrons represents the minimum necessary capability to defend a Carrier Strike Group (CSG).

Altogether, ensuring the minimum necessary air defence of the UK, meeting NATO and multi-national commitments and supporting continuous carrier strike capability requires growth to a minimum of ten frontline Squadrons plus a Flight based in the Falklands.

The number of frontline Squadrons could evolve as below:
2023 - 2 F-35B + 7 Typhoon - 809 NAS stood up
2026 - 3 F-35B + 6 Typhoon - IX(B) transferred from Typhoon to F-35B
2029 - 4 F-35B + 6 Typhoon - 801 NAS stood up
2032 - 5 F-35B + 5 Typhoon - 12(B) transferred from Typhoon to F-35B.


F-35B Lightning II

In UK service the F-35B Lightning II has principally been developed to operate from the Queen Elizabeth class aircraft carriers, each of which is capable of carrying up to three Squadrons.

Entry into frontline service has been slower than intended due to financial constraints and delays in both the development of the aircraft and the Block 4 software upgrade. The result is that there will only be 41 F-35B aircraft in service by 2024 (42 ordered but one crashed into the sea) and 47 by 2025. With so few aircraft available, the second frontline Squadron only stood up in late 2023. In the short-term, that means the UK’s F-35Bs will be required to concentrate on fleet air defence and anti-shipping. The first batch of the F-35B carried two AMRAAM AIM-120C5, two ASRAAM Block 4 and up to four Paveway IV.
F-35B.jpg
Upgraded hardware (Technical Refresh-3) is currently being fitted to new aircraft laying the groundwork for an advanced AESA radar (AN/AG-85) in 2025 and the long awaited Block 4 software upgrade in 2028. It is intended that these improvements will be retrofitted to older aircraft by 2030. This will enable the integration of the more advanced ASRAAM Block 6 in 2025. After that will come the integration of the Meteor Beyond Visual Range Air-to-Air Missile (BVRAAM) in 2027 and SPEAR 3/-EW medium-range precision strike and electronic warfare (-EW) cruise missiles in 2028. The Hypersonic Strike missile and long-range Future Cruise/Anti-Shipping Weapon (FC/ASW) will become available for integration from 2030 and 2031 respectively.

In its fleet air defence role, the F-35B is currently armed with four AMRAAM AIM-120C5 internally and two ASRAAM Block 4. After 2027, they will be upgraded to carry four Meteor BVRAAM internally and two ASRAAM Block 6. In the anti-shipping, land strike and Suppression of Enemy Air Defences (SEAD) roles they will be armed with eight SPEAR 3/-EW internally and either two FC/ASW or two Hypersonic Strike missiles.

Negotiations are currently taking place for the order of the second batch of aircraft. Indications are that Air Command wants to order 27 F-35Bs to enter service between 2026-31, bringing the total to 74. A final batch of eighteen could be ordered between 2032-35 to take the total to 92. From 2035 the Combat Air budget would switch to funding the introduction of the Tempest aircraft as part of the Global Combat Air Programme (GCAP). Under this schedule a third F-35B frontline Squadron could stand up in 2026, followed by a fourth in 2029 and fifth in 2032.


Peak Typhoon

Since 2019, the Eurofighter Typhoon has equipped seven frontline and two reserve Squadrons plus a Flight in the Falklands. It remains the most numerous aircraft in service with the RAF, even after the early retirement of sixteen twin-seat aircraft in a Reduce-to-Produce (RTP) programme involving the recycling of spare parts.

Under IR21, the backbone of the air defence fighter force remained thirty single-seat tranche 1 Typhoons. IRR23 has given the MoD the chance to reassess the minimum number of combat aircraft required. As a result, the bulk of these, rather than all of them, are being withdrawn from 2025 with the final four leaving service in 2027. This plan would see the number of combat aircraft in Air Command cut from 178 in 2024 to 167 in 2027, before climbing to 181 by 2031 and 188 in 2035. In this scenario, one frontline Typhoon Squadron would stand down in 2025 and a second in 2032.

Tranche 1 aircraft currently specialise in the QRA/air defence role. This ensures the maximum use of older airframes while preserving more advanced tranche 3 Typhoons to 2040 and beyond. Their last upgrade took place in 2018 when an order was placed for 200 AMRAAM AIM-120D long-range missiles, equipped with the latest electronic countermeasures. While the Captor M-Scan radar remains the best in its class it is gradually falling behind the latest AESA radars.
Centurion Typhoon.png
In contrast, tranche 2 and 3 Typhoons have experienced several major enhancements through Project Centurion. This has already resulted in the integration of Paveway IV, Storm Shadow, Meteor BVRAAM, Brimstone 3 and ASRAAM Block 6. The Typhoon Phase 4 Enhancements (P4E) programme is dependent on additional savings being produced from the Typhoon Total Available eNterprise (TyTAN) agreement. In the QRA/air defence roles it would be desirable for tranche 2 and 3 Typhoons to be upgraded to carry six Meteor BVRAAM and four ASRAAM Block 6. It would also be desirable to integrate SPEAR 3/-EW from 2025 plus FC/ASW and Hypersonic Strike missile from 2030.

In the second half of the decade, forty tranche 3 Typhoons will be retrofitted with the world leading ECRS2 multi-function array radar. It would clearly be desirable for this advanced AESA radar to be retrofitted to tranche 2 aircraft as well. If that isn’t affordable, four frontline multi-role Squadrons should each be equipped with six tranche 3 Typhoons and six tranche 2 aircraft operating in pairs to maximise their effectiveness. In addition, both tranche 2 and 3 Typhoons are being upgraded with a new mission-management and cockpit interface, additional resilience for GPS and enhanced navigational precision, and protection against electronic interference.


MPA/ISTAR

An essential requirement for long-range anti-submarine patrol aircraft to guard the approaches to Faslane, defend naval battle groups and cover the large areas of sea around the UK has been partially met by the entry into service of nine Boeing P-8 Poseidon maritime patrol aircraft (MPA).
P-8 Poseidon.jpg
The Poseidon has been purchased with as few modifications as possible to control cost. Each aircraft is equipped with 129 sonobuoys, five Mk 54 light torpedoes fitted with High Altitude Anti-submarine Weapons Capability (HAAWC) or Sting Ray light torpedoes providing a specialist anti-submarine warfare role, four long-range Harpoon II+ anti-shipping missiles and two AMRAAM AIM-120D for air defence.

Significant long-term modification of the Poseidon should include the integration of the FC/ASW and Hypersonic Strike missile to provide a long-range strike capability from 2030. Until this is available a total of 60 Harpoon II+ could be loaned from the US Navy as a stop-gap measure.

This leaves relatively few aircraft to cover a vast area of ocean. Estimates suggest that a minimum of sixteen aircraft are required to patrol the UK’s home waters. Ordering additional Poseidon aircraft is unaffordable under current budget constraints but could be achieved through a partnership between Poseidon MPA and Sea Protector unmanned combat aerial vehicle (UCAV).
Sea Protector UCAV.jpg
The surface fleet is also short of Anti-Submarine Warfare (ASW) aircraft. This is a result of between six to ten Merlin HM2 helicopters being allocated, at any one time, to the Airborne Surveillance and Control (ASaC) role with Crowsnest radar. The concept of operating a naval version of the Protector UCAV from a Queen Elizabeth class aircraft carrier is currently being trialled under Project Mojave. If workable, this would enhance the ASW capabilities of the Carrier Strike Group (CSG) thanks to the increased numbers of ASW aircraft and their longer range and endurance when compared with the Merlin HM2.

A cost effective way to boost ASW capabilities would be to order eight Sea Protector UCAV to partner with the Poseidon MPA and/or Merlin HM2. Each Sea Protector should come equipped with up to 100 sonobuoys, four Sting Ray light torpedoes and advanced Seaspray maritime surveillance radar.

To improve land ISTAR and assist with future conflicts against insurgents sixteen long-range Protector UCAV are replacing ten Reaper UCAV from 2024. They could be armed with up to twelve Brimstone 3 and/or six Paveway IV and possess more than twice the flight endurance of their predecessor.

A significant modernisation of the radar used for airborne and ground based early warning is being currently undertaken. Due to the age and increasing obsolescence of the E-3 Sentry aircraft the decision was taken in 2019 to purchase a more modern system, the Boeing E-7 Wedgetail AEW1. This has the advantage of being based on a similar Boeing 737NG airframe to the Poseidon, so saving on maintenance costs at their shared base at RAF Lossiemouth.
E-7 Wedgetail.jpg
A barely adequate total of five Wedgetail’s were ordered in 2019, but two of these were cancelled in IR21. It should be an essential priority for Air Command to restore the original order for five E-7 Wedgetail AEW1 as soon as possible. As the USAF has announced its intention to order 26 of these aircraft, and NATO has a potential requirement for a further 17, this should significantly reduce unit costs and enable an order to be placed for two additional E-7 Wedgetail to enter service by 2034. To be able to survive on the edge of a contested environment the Wedgetail should come equipped with two AMRAAM AIM-120D for air defence.


Complex Weapons: The Next Generation

The most significant gap in the UK’s defences has been the lack of a Ballistic Missile Defence.

The MoD joined the French-Italian BMD programme in 2022 and is upgrading 400 Aster 30/15 missiles to Aster 30 Block 1B maritime standard with the capability to intercept short/medium-range ballistic missiles and aircraft up to 1,500 kilometres/900 miles. The UK should also order 200 ground based Aster 30 Block 1NT this year with the aim of full deployment by 2026.

Research should continue into the development of Aster 30 Block 2BMD to intercept intermediate- range ballistic missiles up to 3,000 kilometres/1,800 miles.

A number of new and upgraded complex weapons are already on order or under development and will enter service in the next ten years including:

• Meteor BVRAAM developed by a six nation European partnership. Entered service in 2016 on the Typhoon and will be integrated on the F-35B in 2027 with minor changes including clipped tail fins so that it can be stored internally
Meteor BVRAAM.jpg
• ASRAAM Block 6, currently entering service and incorporating a new seeker designed for the CAMM family of Surface-to-Air Missiles with the capability to intercept incoming missiles

• Future Cruise/Anti-Ship Weapon (FC/ASW), being developed by a UK-French-Italian partnership based on a highly manoeuvrable subsonic stealth cruise capability to replace Storm Shadow in 2030 and integrated on Poseidon in 2030 and F-35B in 2031

• Hypersonic Strike missile capability to be developed over seven years entering service in 2030

• 500 Storm Shadow have received a mid-life upgrade with surplus stock gifted to Ukraine

• SPEAR 3 medium-range precision strike and electronic warfare (EW) cruise missiles. Entering service on Typhoon from 2025 and F-35B from 2028 in anti-armour, suppression of enemy air defences (SEAD) and anti-shipping roles. Development is also being undertaken to create a networked swarm capability
SPEAR 3.jpg
• Brimstone 3A anti-armour missile variant with improved software and increased range when launched from combat aircraft and Brimstone 3B variant for Protector UCAV and Wildcat AH1

• a Penetrator Warhead for Paveway IV and

• Sky Sabre ground based air defence system.


Hawk Replacement

Currently just eighteen Hawk T1/1A remain in service with the Red Arrows These aircraft fulfil a valuable role promoting the RAF and British engineering. They are due to be retired in 2030 and should be replaced by a new British aircraft, which is currently planned to be twelve Aeralis Aggressive trainers.

In an emergency, the Hawk T2 at RAF Valley, Hawk 167 of the Joint Qatari Hawk Squadron at RAF Leeming and the Aeralis Aggressive trainers at RAF Waddington could take on the role of escorting significant air assets and defending them from the growing threat of Very Long Range Air-to-Air Missiles (VLRAAM) and Very Long Range Surface-to-Air Missiles (VLRSAM).

While they lack internal space for radar these advanced Hawks could use Link 16 and be armed with four ASRAAM Block 6 to provide a dedicated fighter escort for P-8 Poseidon maritime patrol aircraft, E-7 Wedgetail AEW1 aircraft, Voyager tankers and RC-135W Air Seeker electronic surveillance aircraft.


Global Airlift

The ability to transport heavy equipment anywhere in the world is a key part of the UK’s global reach. 22 Airbus A400M Atlas and 8 Boeing C-17 Globemasters share this role between them.

Up until recently they had been supported by a Squadron of Hercules C4 but their retirement was announced as part of IR21. In 2022 it was suggested that an order for an additional six A400M could maintain the RAF’s airlift capabilities. However, a more recent report by the independent NAO has suggested that this is unaffordable within existing budgets.


Basing

The programme outlined in A Better Defence Estate, November 2016, and two announcements made since then, was intended to lead to the disposal of up to fourteen airfields by 2030.

While the Strategic Approach for this rationalisation may have made sense in the world prior to Russia’s growing assertiveness, this is clearly no longer the case today. There are potentially militarily valuable airbases on the current disposal list that should be maintained at a minimum operational level. This could even mean that they are used commercially, but for purposes that do not harm their runways and buildings, such as the solar farms at RAF Coltishall and RAF West Raynham.

There are several criteria that could be used to assess the military value of these bases including the presence of hardened facilities such as Hardened Aircraft Shelters (HAS), a long runway of at least 2,500 metres and significant dispersal areas. This new criteria need not apply to bases in the South-East where additional housing is most required.

Four airbases that the MoD had intended for disposal should be maintained:

1. MoD Woodbridge Airfield. Planned to be closed in 2027 but has eighteen HAS and a 2,700 metre runway. Closure was cancelled in 2019;

2. RAF Mildenhall. USAFE base due to close in 2024. Has a 2,800 metre runway. Closure was cancelled by the USAFE in 2020;

3. RAF Scampton. Closed in 2022 when the Red Arrows relocated. Has a 2,700 metre runway. Is currently being used as housing for asylum seekers and;

4. RAF Wyton. Permission given for car storage up to 2028. Has a 2,500 metre runway.

As the MoD needs to reduce its running costs and maximise the proceeds it receives from selling land it should re-examine several airbases located in London and the South-East, particularly those with good transport links. Prime amongst these should be RAF Northolt. Located within the M25, next to the A40 with both mainline and underground rail services. This site could reach a premium price in the hands of the right developer.

Consideration should also be given to re-locating Air Command Headquarters from RAF High Wycombe to a geographically central, but cheaper, location such as RAF Shawbury.

Responding to Russia’s growing assertiveness three forward air bases are currently being operated from in Eastern Europe at Amari in Estonia, Siaulia in Lithuania and Mihail Kogalniceanu in Romania.


Conclusion

In total, there are fourteen proposals listed here building on the IRR23 and prioritised between those that are essential, desirable and optional.

Those that are essential priorities include:
• purchasing 200 ground-launched Aster 30 Block 1NT and developing Aster 30 Block 2BMD
• placing an additional order for at least 27 F-35B by 2031 and up to 18 more by 2035
• retrofitting tranche 2 Typhoons with ECRS2 multi-function array AESA radar
• equipping P-8 Poseidon with Sting Ray light torpedoes (ordered, November 2023) and air-launched Harpoon II+ loaned from the USN (MoD statement, October 2019)
• developing and ordering eight Sea Protector UCAV with sonobuoys and Sting Ray light torpedoes and
• purchasing at least two, and preferably four, additional E-7 Wedgetail AEW1 by 2035 (five ordered March 2019, but cut to three in IR21).

Those that are desirable include:
• standing up a tenth frontline Squadron
• integrating SPEAR 3/-ER from 2025 plus FC/ASW and Hypersonic Strike missiles from 2030 on tranche 2 and 3 Typhoons
• enabling tranche 2 and 3 Typhoons in the QRA/air defence roles to carry six Meteor BVRAAM and four ASRAAM Block 6
• integrating four ASRAAM Block 6 on 37 Hawk T2
• replacing Red Arrows Hawk T1/1A with 12 Aeralis Aggressive trainers and
• operating three forward air bases in Eastern Europe (Amari in Estonia, Siaulia in Lithuania and Mihail Kogalniceanu in Romania).


And those that are optional include:
• placing an order for six A400M Atlas and
• maintaining two additional airbases that have hardened facilities, long runways or significant dispersal areas while developing RAF Northolt and RAF High Wycombe for housing.



Air Command 2024-31 could operate:
• 41 F-35B Lightning II in 4 Squadrons to 74 in 6 Squadrons
• 137 Typhoons in 9 Squadrons to 107 in 7 Squadrons
• 10 Reaper UCAV in 2 Squadrons to be replaced by 16 Protector UCAV in 2 Squadrons
• 9 P-8 Poseidon in 2 Squadrons
• 8 Sea Protector UCAV in 1 Squadron
• 3 E-7 Wedgetail AEW1 in 1 Squadron to 5 as soon as possible
• 3 Air Seeker R1 in 1 Squadron
• 8 Shadow R1/R2 in 1 Squadron
• 200 ground-launched Aster 30 Block 1NT from 2026
• 640 to 1,220 Meteor BVRAAM
• 200 AMRAAM AIM-120D
• 250 AMRAAM AIM-120C5, OSD 2027
• 600 to 1,100 ASRAAM Block 6
• 130 ASRAAM Block 4, OSD 2025
• 220 FC/ASW SPEAR 5 from 2030
• 500 Storm Shadow, OSD 2030
• 220 Hypersonic Strike missiles from 2030
• 1,900 SPEAR 3/-EW from 2025
• 1,250 Brimstone 3 upgraded to 900 Brimstone 3A and 700 Brimstone 3B
• 3,500 Paveway IV
• 60 air-launched Harpoon II+ on loan from USN, OSD 2030
• 70 Mk 54 light torpedoes with HAAWC
• 120 Sting Ray light torpedoes
• 37 Hawk T2 in 3 Squadrons
• 12 Hawk T1/1A in 1 Squadron to 12 Aeralis Aggressors in 1 Squadron
• 14 Voyager KC2/3 in 2 Squadrons
• 8 C-17 Globemaster in 1 Squadron and
• 22 Atlas C1 in 3 Squadrons.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
These users liked the author AndyC for the post (total 3):
solPhil Sayerswargame_insomniac

downsizer
Member
Posts: 893
Joined: 02 May 2015, 08:03

Re: Air Command Integrated Review Refresh 2023

Post by downsizer »

Great fantasy piece.

Now do what is really happening.

new guy
Senior Member
Posts: 1184
Joined: 18 Apr 2023, 01:53
United Kingdom

Re: Air Command Integrated Review Refresh 2023

Post by new guy »

Some of my takeaways:
1. Worrying how MoD treats its property sell-offs as if it is sustainable, with the MoD getting the same amount of property that it is
selling off. it is UNSUSTAINABLE.

2. As for need more bases for better servivablility, why not pull a thing similar (but different) to what Finland and Sweden do. My
proposal is a formed partnership with the Department for transport, where we give them better funding for a X amount of
countryside roads. We then pay John the farmer to build an inconspicuous warehouse that he could never fill completely, and boom.
Yes I acknowledge flaws. Mixed commercial/MoD use and mothballing is far more viable.

3. F-35. US DoD ordered 126 for $7.8bn recently. That is ~£50m per unit. £50m per unit. Yes it was a mix of A,B,C variants but why is
the latest batch costing £94m?????? Even for MoD's varying budget methods, it is actively perplexing. It makes a difference, as
probably 40 F-35 for £2.5bn is US DoD methods.

4. I believe MQ-9B was £25m per unit, based of last UK order for 13. On the other hand, I would be fine for a order worth £900m, If we
get closer to 36 with a few STOL wings chucked in.

5. Supporting Aeralis is essential.

User avatar
AndyC
Member
Posts: 169
Joined: 11 Dec 2015, 10:37
United Kingdom

Re: Air Command Integrated Review Refresh 2023

Post by AndyC »

In answer to your point 3 it has been very challenging to esimate the precise Unit Recurring Flyaway (URF) cost for future years because the information for past contracts is released long after the event.

So in general I have tended to err on the side of caution. The U$ price I've used above is U$115 million which is LRIP11 https://ukdefencejournal.org.uk/latest- ... st-orders/

This was the situation as Covid spread and you can certainly see plenty of media articles predicting the cost would rise in the pandemic.

However, the DoD decided to merge LRIP12-14 into one larger order. Only last November was it revealed, as a result of a Parliamentary question, that in fact the URF for the F-35B had come down to U$101 million https://questions-statements.parliament ... 1-22/93484

Since then we've learned that the cost of an F-35B in LRIP15-17 is U$80.9 million for the airframe https://www.airandspaceforces.com/30-bi ... eries-dip/ plus U$17.7 million for engines https://www.thedefensepost.com/2023/03/ ... -contract/

So altogether the latest URF for the seven F-35B entering service in 2025 is U$98.6 million. Based on this figure I've re-worked the budget estimates.

It still seems to me that ordering six A400M Atlas is unaffordable but there is a bit more room to fund some of the Typhoon enhancements even if TyTAN doesn't deliver all £500 million of efficiency savings.

SW1
Senior Member
Posts: 5657
Joined: 27 Aug 2018, 19:12
United Kingdom

Re: Air Command Integrated Review Refresh 2023

Post by SW1 »

I don’t know why you’re attempting to use URF costs for budgeting it’s an irrelevant number if you want something that isn’t a paperweight. It will cost the defence budget significantly more than that with added spares equipment ect. The closest example you could use, would be japans addition of 105 a/c in 2020 at a cost of 23 billion dollars as a guide.

You will then have to factor in which aircraft from the current fleet will be economical to upgrade to latest standard which will likely need to include the new engine core. Or which will be scrapped when the yanks stop supporting the configuration they are at.

User avatar
AndyC
Member
Posts: 169
Joined: 11 Dec 2015, 10:37
United Kingdom

Re: Air Command Integrated Review Refresh 2023

Post by AndyC »

UPDATE
The Sea Protector UCAV is currently being trialled under Project Mojave, to examine whether they can operate from a Queen Elizabeth class aircraft carrier. This would enhance the Anti-Submarine Warfare (ASW) capabilities of the Carrier Strike Group (CSG) thanks to the increased numbers of ASW assets this represents and their longer range and endurance when compared to Merlin HMA2 helicopters.
See https://ukdefencejournal.org.uk/british ... er-drones/

and https://www.navylookout.com/could-marit ... -carriers/

Also, in 2022 Taiwan bought four Sea Guardians for U$555 milion (U$138.75 million unit cost) and Greece bought three for U$400 milion (U$133.33 million).

new guy
Senior Member
Posts: 1184
Joined: 18 Apr 2023, 01:53
United Kingdom

Re: Air Command Integrated Review Refresh 2023

Post by new guy »

AndyC wrote: 24 May 2023, 07:59 UPDATE
The Sea Protector UCAV is currently being trialled under Project Mojave, to examine whether they can operate from a Queen Elizabeth class aircraft carrier. This would enhance the Anti-Submarine Warfare (ASW) capabilities of the Carrier Strike Group (CSG) thanks to the increased numbers of ASW assets this represents and their longer range and endurance when compared to Merlin HMA2 helicopters.
See https://ukdefencejournal.org.uk/british ... er-drones/

and https://www.navylookout.com/could-marit ... -carriers/

Also, in 2022 Taiwan bought four Sea Guardians for U$555 milion (U$138.75 million unit cost) and Greece bought three for U$400 milion (U$133.33 million).
In ~2019 we got +13 skyguardians / protectors for £195m, or £15m each.

User avatar
AndyC
Member
Posts: 169
Joined: 11 Dec 2015, 10:37
United Kingdom

Re: Air Command Integrated Review Refresh 2023

Post by AndyC »

According to the MoD's latest Major Projects report the total budget for Protector is currently estimated at £1.517 billion. That comes to £94.8 million or U$117.6 milllon each.

The dfference between the UK's price and Taiwan/Greece is probably down to a combination of economies of scale plus additional development costs for Sea Guardian compared to Sky Guardian.

User avatar
AndyC
Member
Posts: 169
Joined: 11 Dec 2015, 10:37
United Kingdom

Re: Air Command Integrated Review Refresh 2023

Post by AndyC »

Air Command and Strategic Programmes Top Level Budgets 2023-33.


Based on the MoD defence equipment plan 2023, published on December 4th.

Total of £23.1 billion in Uncommitted Equipment Procurement, as of March 2023.

Consolidating the Top Level Budgets for Strategic Programmes (£16.3 billion, including £6.4 billion on Weapons Operating Centre Budget) and Air Command (£6.8 billion, including £4.9 billion on Combat Air and £1.5 billion on Air Support).


£20.3 billion contained in IR21, but not committed under contract as of March 2023:

• £8.7 billion uncommitted on Global Combat Air Programme (GCAP) - £1.8 billion spent so far out of £2 billion committed by 2025 from £10.7 billion whole life cost (Parliamentary answer, February 2024). The decision by Japan, in December 2022, to join this UK-Italian partnership will help keep the overall development costs of GCAP under control

• £6.4 billion on Weapons Operating Centre Budget. Co-operation with international partners to update the Meteor BVRAAM, the decision by Italy to join the UK-French FC/ASW programme and the UK to join the French-Italian BMD programme plus the global success of CAMM should keep the costs of the UK’s complex weapons budgets under control

• £2.97 billion for the second batch of 27 F-35B entering service between 2026-31 plus 18 between 2032-35 – unit cost U$115 million, £/U$ rate 1.22

• £2.04 billion for ECRS2 radar development (£870 million contract signed, July 2023) and £1.17 billion for retrofit on tranche 2 and 3 Typhoons and

• £170 million on novel weapons.


£2 billion for essential extras:

• £1.1 billion for two additional E-7 Wedgetail – unit cost £550 million (excluding 5 x £60 million MESA radar already purchased) and

• £890 million for eight Sea Protector UCAV – unit cost U$136 million (Taiwan paid U$555 million for four and Greece paid U$400 million for three in 2022), £/U$ rate 1.22.


£800 million on desirable extras:

• £400 million for spiral development of tranche 2 and 3 Typhoons including integration of SPEAR 3/-EW, FC/ASW and Hypersonic Strike missiles and upgrade to carry six Meteor BVRAAM plus four ASRAAM Block 6 in the QRA/air defence roles

• £360 million for 12 Aeralis Aggressor trainers – unit cost £30 million and

• £40 million to integrate four ASRAAM Block 6 on 37 Hawk T2 – unit cost £1 million.


£740 million of optional extras:

• £740 million for six A400M Atlas – unit cost €140 million, £/€ rate 1.14 and

Optional extras are unaffordable due to £800 million overspend.
These users liked the author AndyC for the post:
new guy

Post Reply